During a water quality testing drive organised by the Jal Jeevan Mission at a rural primary school in Sitapur, Uttar Pradesh, science teacher Ms. Rekha demonstrated indicator tests on three water samples collected from different sources — a hand pump (Sample A), a nearby pond (Sample B), and a factory drain outlet (Sample C). She tested each sample with litmus solution, phenolphthalein, and methyl orange. Sample A turned litmus purple and gave no colour change with phenolphthalein; Sample B turned red litmus blue and turned phenolphthalein pink; Sample C turned blue litmus red, turned methyl orange to red, and a strip of turmeric paper dipped in it turned reddish-brown. The pH values recorded for Samples A, B, and C were 7, 10, and 3 respectively.
During a water quality testing drive organised by the Jal Jeevan Mission at a rural primary school in Sitapur, Uttar Pradesh, science teacher Ms. Rekha demonstrated indicator tests on three water samples collected from different sources — a hand pump (Sample A), a nearby pond (Sample B), and a factory drain outlet (Sample C). She tested each sample with litmus solution, phenolphthalein, and methyl orange. Sample A turned litmus purple and gave no colour change with phenolphthalein; Sample B turned red litmus blue and turned phenolphthalein pink; Sample C turned blue litmus red, turned methyl orange to red, and a strip of turmeric paper dipped in it turned reddish-brown. The pH values recorded for Samples A, B, and C were 7, 10, and 3 respectively.
Show answerHide answer
(b) Sample B (pH = 10) turned phenolphthalein pink and turned red litmus blue, confirming it is basic (alkaline) in nature. A common laboratory chemical that would produce these results is sodium hydroxide (NaOH).
(c) Litmus is a natural indicator that shows three distinct behaviours depending on the nature of the solution: it turns red in acidic solutions (blue litmus turns red — Sample C, pH = 3), remains purple with no colour change in neutral solutions (Sample A, pH = 7), and turns blue in basic solutions (red litmus turns blue — Sample B, pH = 10). Therefore, litmus can effectively distinguish between all three types of solutions — acidic, neutral, and basic.
OR
(c) Sample A (hand pump water, pH = 7) is the safest for drinking among the three samples. It gave no colour change with phenolphthalein, turned litmus purple, and has a pH of 7, indicating it is neutral in nature. Safe drinking water should have a pH close to 7. Sample B is alkaline (pH = 10) and Sample C is strongly acidic (pH = 3), likely contaminated by factory effluents — both are unsuitable for drinking as they deviate significantly from neutral pH and may contain harmful dissolved chemicals.