A biotechnology company is developing a transgenic soybean to resist both a lepidopteran pod borer and the soybean cyst nematode (Heterodera glycines) simultaneously. Strategy 1 uses a cry gene from Bacillus thuringiensis. Strategy 2 uses RNAi to silence the nematode's essential cpc-1 gene (cytochrome P450). A construct expressed in soybean root cells produces dsRNA complementary to cpc-1 mRNA; the nematode ingests this dsRNA while feeding on the roots.
Read the following passage and answer the questions that follow:
A biotechnology company is developing a transgenic crop to address two simultaneous agricultural problems. The target plant is a soybean variety that suffers heavy yield losses due to (i) attack by a specific lepidopteran pest (pod borer), and (ii) infection by a soil-dwelling parasitic nematode (Heterodera glycines — soybean cyst nematode). The scientists decide to use two different biotechnological strategies in the SAME plant:
• Strategy 1: Introduction of a specific cry gene from Bacillus thuringiensis to confer insect resistance.
• Strategy 2: Use of RNA interference (RNAi) technology to silence a nematode-specific essential gene (cpc-1, encoding a cytochrome P450 essential for nematode survival).
For Strategy 2, the scientists design a construct that, when expressed in the soybean root cells, produces double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) complementary to the nematode's cpc-1 mRNA. When the nematode feeds on root cells, it ingests this dsRNA.
(a) In Strategy 1, the cry gene product exists as an inactive protoxin inside the bacterial cell. Explain the two-step mechanism by which this protoxin becomes lethal to the pod borer larva but does NOT harm humans consuming the crop. [2 marks]
(b) In Strategy 2, trace the molecular pathway from the moment the nematode ingests the dsRNA to the ultimate silencing of the cpc-1 gene. Name the specific enzyme and the intermediate molecule involved. [2 marks]
Show answerHide answer
─────────────────────────────────────────
Part (a): Mechanism of Bt toxin — [2 marks]
─────────────────────────────────────────
Step 1 — Solubilisation in alkaline midgut (½ mark):
• The cry gene in soybean cells is expressed as an INACTIVE protoxin (crystalline Bt toxin protein).
• When the pod borer larva ingests plant tissue, the protoxin enters the highly ALKALINE (high pH) midgut of the insect.
• In this alkaline environment, the protoxin is SOLUBILISED (dissolved).
Step 2 — Activation by midgut proteases and mechanism of lethality (1 mark):
• Proteases present in the insect's midgut cleave the protoxin → produce the ACTIVE TOXIN form.
• The active toxin binds to specific receptor proteins on the epithelial cells lining the midgut.
• It creates PORES (ion channels) in the epithelial cell membrane → causes cell swelling and lysis → disrupts midgut integrity → insect dies.
Why it does NOT harm humans (½ mark):
• Human gut is ACIDIC (low pH) — the protoxin is NOT solubilised.
• Even if solubilised, human intestinal cells LACK the specific receptor proteins required for the toxin to bind and form pores.
• Therefore, the protoxin passes through the human digestive system without being activated or binding, posing no harm.
─────────────────────────────────────────
Part (b): RNAi molecular pathway — [2 marks]
─────────────────────────────────────────
Step-by-step molecular pathway:
1. INGESTION (¼ mark):
• The nematode (Heterodera glycines) feeds on soybean root cells and ingests the double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) complementary to cpc-1 mRNA.
2. DICER ACTION — enzyme named (½ mark):
• Inside the nematode cells, the enzyme DICER (an RNase III-type endonuclease) recognises and cleaves the ingested long dsRNA.
• Dicer cuts the dsRNA into short fragments of ~21–23 nucleotide pairs called siRNA (small interfering RNA) — the key intermediate molecule.
3. RISC FORMATION (½ mark):
• The siRNA is incorporated into a multi-protein complex called RISC (RNA-Induced Silencing Complex).
• The double-stranded siRNA is unwound within RISC; the antisense (guide) strand is retained.
4. TARGET mRNA DEGRADATION → gene silencing (¾ mark):
• The antisense siRNA strand within RISC guides the complex to the complementary cpc-1 mRNA of the nematode (by Watson-Crick base pairing).
• RISC cleaves the cpc-1 mRNA → the mRNA is degraded.
• Result: cpc-1 mRNA is no longer translated → cytochrome P450 enzyme is NOT produced → the nematode CANNOT survive → nematode dies or fails to establish infection in soybean roots.
Summary pathway (to write as a flowchart in answer book):
dsRNA (ingested by nematode)
↓ [DICER — endonuclease]
siRNA (~21–23 bp) — intermediate
↓ [incorporated into RISC complex]
RISC–siRNA complex
↓ [base pairs with cpc-1 mRNA]
cpc-1 mRNA cleaved and degraded
↓
No Cytochrome P450 produced
↓
Nematode death / cpc-1 gene silenced
─────────────────────────────────────────
VALUE POINTS SUMMARY (Examiner Reference)
─────────────────────────────────────────
(a) ½ + 1 + ½ = 2 marks
• Alkaline pH solubilises protoxin — ½
• Midgut proteases activate toxin → pores in epithelial cells → lysis — 1
• Humans: acidic pH + no specific receptors — ½
(b) ½ + ½ + ¾ + ¼ = 2 marks
• Dicer (enzyme named correctly) — ½
• siRNA (intermediate named correctly) — ½
• RISC formation + antisense strand guides complex — ½
• cpc-1 mRNA degraded → no protein → nematode silenced — ½
(Award full 2 marks if all four elements: dsRNA → Dicer → siRNA → RISC → mRNA degradation are correctly traced with enzyme and intermediate named)