A forensic chemistry student is analysing two colourless liquid samples labelled P and Q. Sample P is 1-bromobutane and Sample Q is 2-bromobutane. Both samples are treated separately with aqueous NaOH under identical conditions. The student observes that the two samples undergo hydrolysis at different rates and give products with different stereochemical outcomes.
A forensic chemistry student is analysing two colourless liquid samples labelled P and Q. Sample P is 1-bromobutane and Sample Q is 2-bromobutane. Both samples are treated separately with aqueous NaOH under identical conditions. The student observes that the two samples undergo hydrolysis at different rates and give products with different stereochemical outcomes.
(a) Which sample, P or Q, undergoes hydrolysis faster? Give ONE reason for your answer. (2 marks)
(b) The hydrolysis of Sample Q with aqueous NaOH proceeds with Walden inversion. Identify the mechanism involved and justify why Walden inversion is NOT observed when Sample Q is instead heated with aqueous AgNO₃. (2 marks)
Show answerHide answer
(a) Sample P (1-bromobutane) undergoes hydrolysis FASTER. [½ mark for identifying P]
Reason: 1-Bromobutane is a primary alkyl halide. It undergoes hydrolysis by the SN2 mechanism, in which the nucleophile (OH⁻) attacks the carbon bearing the leaving group directly. The approach of OH⁻ to the less hindered primary carbon is sterically unhindered, so the reaction proceeds with a high rate. 2-Bromobutane is a secondary alkyl halide with greater steric hindrance around the C–Br carbon, which slows the backside attack by the nucleophile. [1½ marks for the correct reason: primary → less steric hindrance → faster SN2]
∴ P (1-bromobutane) is hydrolysed faster than Q (2-bromobutane).
(b) Mechanism involved in the hydrolysis of Sample Q (2-bromobutane) with aqueous NaOH: SN2 (bimolecular nucleophilic substitution). [½ mark]
In the SN2 mechanism, OH⁻ attacks the back of the C–Br bond in a single concerted step, inverting the configuration at the chiral carbon (Walden inversion) — the product has the opposite configuration to the reactant. [½ mark for the explanation of inversion]
When Sample Q is heated with aqueous AgNO₃, the reaction proceeds by the SN1 mechanism. [½ mark]
Ag⁺ assists the ionisation of the C–Br bond by precipitating AgBr↓, generating a planar carbocation intermediate. The nucleophile (H₂O) can attack this planar carbocation from either face with equal probability, giving a racemic mixture of products. Since attack occurs from both sides, there is no net inversion — Walden inversion is NOT observed. [½ mark for: planar carbocation → attack from both faces → racemisation, not inversion]